Our Buylist Makes Trades Easy

Buylist | Chimera Gaming

Trade-In Rates

TCG Game	Cash	Store Credit
	61%	71%
	60%	70%
	50%	60%
	40%	50%

We offer increased trade-in value for select MTG cards on our Hot Buylist. Check it out for bonus rates on in-demand singles!

How It Works

Log In or Create an Account

You must be logged in to access our Buylist tool. Login or create your account here.
Navigate to the Buylist

Once logged in, go to the Content & Grading tab at the top of our website and select the type of singles you'd like to trade in.
Choose Cash or Store Credit

Prices can be displayed in Cash or Store Credit. We offer higher value for trades toward store credit. See the rates table above.
Build Your List

Use the Buylist search bar to find and add your singles. Select the correct version, finish, and condition for an accurate estimate.

Not sure how to grade your cards? View our Card Conditioning Guide.
Submit Your Buylist

Once your list is complete, click "Submit Buylist", keeping your physical cards in the same order as your digital submission.

Do not send in your cards yet. We still need to review your Buylist before you ship or drop them off.

Online Buylist prices are estimates based on market value. The final price is subject to change after conditioning.
Await Confirmation Emails

Up to 2 emails will be sent: one automatic submission confirmation, and one manual confirmation from our team. Once you receive the manual confirmation, bring your cards in or send them within 2–3 business days.

If there are any cards you no longer wish to sell, simply exclude them. We'll remove them when we receive your Buylist.

Physical Buylists must be un-sleeved and organized to match their digital submission. Failure to do so may result in additional fees.
Card Conditioning

Once we receive your cards, we'll condition them and apply any applicable deductions. We'll then send you an updated total.

If you disagree with a conditioning decision or price change, let us know. You can remove those cards. Returns can be picked up, sent by lettermail, included with another order, or tracked (with a deduction).

All inquiries about changes must be made by email within 48 hours. After that we'll assume you accept any changes and begin processing payment.

If dropping cards off in person, we cannot guarantee they can be conditioned immediately.
Get Paid

Once changes are confirmed (or if there are none), we'll process payment. Store Credit is applied automatically to your account. All Cash payments are sent via E-Transfer.

Mail-In Information

Send Cards To

Chimera Gaming
Attn: Mailed Buylist
700 Strasburg Road, Unit 31
Kitchener, ON, N2E 2M2
Canada

Shipping Tips

We are not responsible for lost or transit-damaged items. Use a tracked method and purchase additional coverage for valuable cards.

Cards under $25 must be un-sleeved. Buylists in disarray or with too many individually sleeved cards may be subject to deductions.

International Sellers: If we are assessed any import duties, tariffs, taxes (excluding GST/HST), or brokerage fees, these amounts will be deducted from your total. Note that Canada Post charges $9.95 CAD per tracked package if they have to collect payment on delivery.